What has changed
Updated on November 20, 2026.
- We previously treated Domain Authority as a Google ranking factor. It is not. Domain Authority is a Moz score for comparing sites, and Google does not use it.
- We said toxic scores and Spam Scores harm your rankings. These are estimates made by SEO tools. Google ignores most spammy links, and disavowing is only needed for a manual action or for links that were bought or built to manipulate rankings.
- We referred to Google Webmaster Tools. It is now Google Search Console, and we updated the list of its reports.
- We said a guest post author does not need to be a real person. Use a real, named author who knows the subject.
One of the most frequent questions we get at diib is “how do I increase my domain authority?” Domain authority is a third-party score, so the better question is how to earn backlinks that help your site. Backlinks (links from other websites to yours) are a key part of off-page SEO (search engine optimization), and which sites link to you matters far more than how many links you have.
Off-page SEO is more strategic than it used to be. Spamming hundreds of backlinks to your site does not work, and buying links or joining link schemes breaks Google’s spam policies. Let’s look at how SEO works and what makes a backlink worth having.
What is SEO?
Search engine optimization (SEO) is a method used to boost the ranking of websites and web pages in search engines like Google, Bing, and others. The purpose of this strategy is to increase “organic traffic,” which is traffic that consists of people actively searching for whatever your website is about. For example, if you have a website selling mufflers, you want people searching for mufflers to land on your site and make a purchase.
The significant benefit of organic traffic is that many of these people are already in a buying mindset. This means that conversions will be higher once they land on your website. As you can imagine, sites and pages that rank higher in the search engine results get a larger portion of this valuable “buyer-ready” traffic and can profit greatly from it.
Many factors determine how your website and its pages are ranked in the search engine results. Here is a quick list of the most critical factors that you should be aware of:
- Mobile friendly design
- Load speed
- Keyword density
- Internal linking structure
- External links
- Backlinks
- Intuitive navigation
- High-quality content
- Website security
Some of these factors, such as how fast your web pages load, fall under the category of “on-page” SEO. Others, such as backlinks, fall under the “off-page” SEO category. To develop an effective SEO strategy, it’s essential to understand the difference between the two and how they play their part in boosting your website’s rankings.
On-Page SEO vs. Off-Page SEO

(Image Credit: WordStream)
On-Page SEO
On-page SEO is anything that you do on your site that affects your search engine ranking. This applies to keyword density, navigation, and making sure your site is mobile-friendly. On-page SEO is time-consuming but very easy to control and optimize. There is no reason any business owner should avoid optimizing their website for on-page SEO.
Off-Page SEO
Off-page SEO consists of factors that affect your search engine rankings from external sources. The most well-known form of off-page SEO is backlinks. This is when another site links to your own site and, in doing so, affects your search engine ranking. Brick-and-mortar businesses make heavy use of this by listing their business in various business directories online and with services like Google Maps.
So, which is more powerful, on-page or off-page SEO? The answer is complicated. On-page SEO is essential for any SEO strategy. Without it, your campaign will be sunk before it even begins. On the other hand, off-page SEO has the potential to be more powerful. This is especially true when geo-targeting SEO is needed for businesses with physical locations. Earning links from relevant, trustworthy websites matters far more than chasing any third-party score. Done wrong, off-page SEO can do more harm than good.
Why Backlinking is so Powerful
To understand why backlinking is such a powerful off-page SEO tactic, it’s vital to first grasp what the concept of “authority” means. When another website links to yours, you can think of it as an endorsement. For example, if your next-door neighbor told you that you’re a good basketball player, that’s a nice compliment. However, if Michael Jordan or Lebron James told you that you’re a good basketball player, their opinion would carry much more weight or “authority.”
It’s the same with backlinking. A link from a respected, relevant website tells search engines much more than a link from an obscure site with no real audience. This is why off-page SEO now focuses on the quality of backlinks rather than the quantity. The backlink farms of the 2000s are dead. Google’s systems ignore most low-quality links, and deliberately building links to manipulate rankings can lead to a manual action.
***Did you know??
- An Ahrefs study found that 43.7% of top ranking pages in Google contain reciprocal links (Ahrefs)
- Companies who engage in blogging receive 97% more backlinks to their site (Hubspot)
Domain Authority
Domain Authority (DA) is a score from 1 to 100 created by Moz, an SEO software company, to predict how likely a website is to rank compared with other sites. Other SEO tools have similar scores. These scores are useful for a quick comparison, but they are third-party estimates. Google does not use Domain Authority or any of these scores in its rankings, and raising your score does not by itself raise your rankings.
When you size up a site for a backlink, ask better questions than “what is its score?”
- Is the site relevant to your business, industry or local area?
- Do real people read it? Look for recent posts, real comments and an active audience.
- Does it publish useful, original content, or is it mostly ads and posts that exist only to sell links?
- Would the link make sense to a reader and send you visitors even if search engines did not exist?
A link from a small, relevant local site that passes those tests is often worth more to your business than a link from a high-DA site in an unrelated niche. Use DA as one rough signal for comparing sites, not as a target.
Toxic Score & Spam Score
Many SEO tools label backlinks as “toxic” or give sites a “spam score.” These labels come from the tool makers, not from Google. Google has said its systems are good at spotting spammy links and simply ignoring them, so a random low-quality link pointing at your site usually does not hurt you.
Toxic Score
A toxic score is a tool’s guess at whether a link looks unnatural, based on warning signs such as:
- Link networks or link farms
- Sites containing malware
- Sites that are not indexed by Google
- Spam sites created only to host links
These are sensible things to check before you ask a site for a link. They are not a Google penalty score, and Google does not see your tool’s toxicity rating.
What can hurt you is taking part in link schemes yourself. Google’s spam policies cover buying or selling links for ranking, excessive link swaps, private blog networks and automated link building. If Google finds a pattern of manipulative links, it can issue a manual action, which you will see in the Manual actions report in Google Search Console.
If you have a manual action for unnatural links, or you know links were bought or built on your behalf, first ask the site owners to remove them. Use Google’s disavow links tool only for the links you cannot get removed. If you have no manual action and did not build the links, Google says you generally do not need to disavow anything.

(Image Credit: Grow Hack Scale)
Spam Score
Spam Score is a Moz metric that estimates how similar a site is to sites Moz has seen penalized or banned by Google. It is a useful way to spot sites worth a closer look, but like Domain Authority, it is a third-party estimate and not a Google ranking factor. A high Spam Score on a site that links to you does not automatically harm your rankings.
The practical lesson is the same for both scores: check a site yourself before you pursue a link from it, avoid anything that looks like a link farm, and do not spend time chasing down every low-quality link a tool flags.
What Content to Write for Backlinks
There are many ways to get backlinks, but one of the most powerful is guest posting. Guest posting is when you write a blog post or article and allow another site to post it for free. In return, they give you a link back to your website. There are many benefits to this, such as:
- Build brand awareness
- Reach out to a new audience
- Build trust and authority
- Generate qualified leads
- Expand your backlinking profile
- Get targeted traffic
- Boost your SEO
The key to successful guest posting is knowing what kind of content to write and which sites to approach. In most cases, you want to write for websites in the same niche, industry or area as you, with an audience that would want to hear from you. A smaller site in your niche with engaged readers can be a better fit than a bigger site with a higher third-party score, because what you want is targeted traffic and qualified leads.
Keep it genuine. Google’s spam policies treat large-scale guest posting campaigns with keyword-rich anchor text links as a link scheme, so write guest posts to reach new readers, not just to collect links.
The best content to write for this strategy presents you as an authority in your niche or industry and showcases your expertise. Publish under a real, named person from your business, such as you or a team member who knows the subject. Readers trust content more when they can see who wrote it and why that person knows the topic.
The content should also be helpful to the reader and focus on engagement. In the end, it should leave the reader wanting more. This will lead directly into the CTA (call to action) that will prompt the reader to click your link and visit your website. From there, you can market to this new traffic source however you want.
***Key Stats on Content Development:
- 61% of companies outsource content marketing efforts (Source)
- 57% of marketing executives view content development as the most effective SEO strategy (Source)
Different SEO Tools to Use
While backlinking may be more complicated these days, there are plenty of different SEO tools to use that can make it easier for you. Let’s take a look at some of the most powerful SEO tools available today, what they’re used for, and why you should be using them.
Google Search Console (formerly Google Webmaster Tools)
Google Search Console is Google’s free tool for website owners. It replaced Google Webmaster Tools in 2015. If you are not using it yet, set it up first. Useful reports include:
- Performance: the searches that show your site and the clicks you get
- Links: your top linking sites, top linked pages and top linking text
- Page indexing: which pages Google has and has not indexed
- Manual actions: whether Google has taken action against your site
- Security issues: warnings about hacked content or malware
The Links report is the most relevant here. It shows who links to you and the anchor text they use (the clickable words in the link), which gives you a free starting point for any backlink review.
Toxic Backlink Checkers
Many paid SEO tools flag “toxic” backlinks. They can help you spot suspicious patterns, but treat their ratings as a prompt to look closer, not as proof of a problem. Google ignores most spammy links on its own, so you only need to act if you have a manual action or know of links that were bought or built to manipulate rankings.
Spam Backlink Checker
Some tools, such as Moz, focus on spam signals and give each site a score. Use these scores to decide which sites deserve a manual check before you pursue a link, not as a list of links you must remove.
On-Page SEO Analysis
Many tools can analyze your on-page SEO factors in one go, and give you advice on what actions you need to take to fully optimize your website. These tools are invaluable for ensuring your website is up to par in categories such as navigation, load speeds, keyword density, and more.
Specialized Tools
There are different SEO tools to use that specialize in helping you improve one specific aspect of SEO. One example would be the plugins that help your website’s pages load faster on WordPress. Some tools can give you keyword advice when typing blog posts and articles. These specialized tools should be used as needed to shore up SEO deficiencies on your website.
Off-Page SEO Done Right
The best backlinks come from sites that are relevant to your business and that real people read. A high third-party score can be a helpful hint, but relevance, a real audience and honest editorial links matter more than any number.
Before you pursue a link, look at the site yourself. Then keep an eye on the Links and Manual actions reports in Google Search Console. If you have no manual action, you do not need to prune links a tool calls toxic. Spend that time creating content and relationships that earn good links instead. To see how your website is performing, you can start with a free scan on diib and compare plans on the diib pricing page.
diib Digital: Your Backlink Domain Authority Experts!
Off-page SEO takes patience, and no one can guarantee rankings. diib’s dashboard helps you keep an eye on your backlinks, spot broken pages that other sites link to, and work through plain-English tasks to improve your on-page and off-page SEO. Here are a few of the features included:
- Bounce rate monitoring and repair
- Social media integration and performance
- Broken pages where you have backlinks (404 checker)
- Keyword (including snippets), backlink, and indexing monitoring and tracking tools
- User experience and mobile speed optimization
- Technical SEO monitoring
Click here for your free 60 second site scan or simply call 800-303-3510 to speak to one of our growth experts.
Frequently asked questions
How many backlinks does a small business website need?
There is no set number of backlinks a small business needs. A few links from relevant, trusted sites, such as local news outlets, industry associations and suppliers, often help more than hundreds of weak ones. Compare your links with the competitors who outrank you to see where the gap is.
How long do new backlinks take to affect search rankings?
New backlinks usually take weeks to months to show any effect, because search engines must find and evaluate them first. No one can guarantee that a link will move your rankings. Keep earning relevant links steadily and judge progress over several months using search clicks and impressions.
Is it safe to buy backlinks?
No, buying links that pass ranking value violates Google's spam policies. Paid link schemes, private blog networks and excessive link swaps can lead to a manual action that removes pages from search results. If you pay for a placement, such as a sponsored post, the link should be marked as sponsored or nofollow.
How can a local business earn good backlinks?
Local businesses earn good backlinks by getting involved in their community. Join your chamber of commerce and trade associations, sponsor local events or teams, ask suppliers and partners to list you, pitch stories to local news sites and publish genuinely useful guides that other local sites want to reference.
How do I check which websites link to my site?
Open the Links report in Google Search Console to see your top linking sites, your most linked pages and the anchor text other sites use. The report is free and comes straight from Google. diib also tracks your backlinks over time, so you can see which links you gained or lost.
