What has changed
Updated on November 20, 2026.
- We previously said it never hurts to remove spammy links and that you must disavow toxic links found in a routine audit. Google says its systems ignore most spammy links, so most sites do not need to remove or disavow anything.
- Disavowing is for two cases: you have a manual action for unnatural links, or you know links were bought or built to manipulate rankings. Disavowing the wrong links can hurt your site.
- Toxicity and spam scores come from SEO tools, not Google. We removed claims that these scores affect your rankings.
- Since 2016, Google’s Penguin system mostly ignores spammy links instead of demoting whole sites, so we rewrote the section on algorithmic filters.
SEO experts and website owners take deliberate steps to get their websites on Google’s first page. Sometimes they also worry about “toxic” backlinks: spammy links from low-quality sites pointing at their pages.
The good news is that most businesses never need to remove toxic backlinks. Google has said its systems are good at spotting spammy links, including negative SEO attacks, and simply ignoring them. Links only become a real problem when they are part of a link scheme, such as links you or someone you hired bought, swapped or built to manipulate rankings.
This post explains what toxic links are, when they actually affect you, and what to do in the rare cases where you need to remove or disavow them.
Quality vs. Toxic Backlinks
In general, quality links originate from reliable sources. They can include links that have been placed editorially because someone found your material valuable and linked to it.
On the other hand, according to Google’s link scheme, toxic backlinks from nebulous websites are links meant to manipulate or influence PageRank or a site’s ranking in Google search results and, as such, violate Google’s guidelines.
These types of toxic links are those that are not editorially posted but are actively inserted by an SEO to improve search ranks. Indicators of low-quality links or attempts to manipulate/influence rankings include links from:
- Sites created solely to link out.
- Non-topical sites and content.
- Sites not indexed by Google.
- Forced blog comments.
- A website’s footer.
- Every internet page.
They also include links:
- Using exact match anchor text’ (link text containing commercial ‘money’ terms).
A Backlink Analysis: What Is It & Why Should You Do It?
If you don’t routinely analyze your backlink profile, starting today is best. The more you know about your and your competitors’ link portfolios, the better your strategy can be and improve.

(Image Credit: Semrush)
Find A Competitor Link Gap
This helps you understand your link gap with your top competitors. Understanding your own and your competitors’ link profiles allows you to assess your capacity to rank and how challenging it will be to outdo them. So you can devise a strategy to bridge the gap and obtain a competitive advantage.
You will be operating in the dark without knowing the link characteristics of your competitors’ websites. Using the SEMrush Backlink Gap tool, you can quickly compare up to five domains.
Your plan will be more effective if you compare it to your competitors.
Identify and Eliminate Negative Links to Protect Your Scores
A backlink review helps you understand who links to you and spot anything unusual, such as a sudden burst of links from unrelated sites with keyword-stuffed anchor text.
If you have a manual action for unnatural links in Google Search Console, a backlink review is how you find the links that caused it so you can clean them up and ask Google to reconsider.
If you do not have a manual action, a review is still a useful health check, but most flagged links need no action. Think of it like a routine check-up for your car: you look for real problems, not for reasons to replace parts that work.

(Image Credit: ClickBank)
How Do Toxic Backlinks Affect Organic Rankings?
Toxic links were once widely used and significantly affected rankings. Google’s algorithms have improved dramatically since then, as have its efforts to combat web spam, including unnatural links.
The Google Penguin update of 2012 targeted unnatural links and changed the link-building world. Since Penguin became part of Google’s core algorithm in 2016, it mostly ignores spammy links rather than demoting the whole site that receives them. Today, low-quality links usually just pass no value.
Here are the two ways unnatural links can still affect your site.
Your Website Is Subjected to Manual Action Due to Toxic Backlinks
If Google’s webspam team examines your domain’s link profile and discovers significant spam, they may take manual action. Google itself says:
“A manual action is taken by Google when a human reviewer determines that a site’s pages do not meet Google’s webmaster quality requirements. Most manual activities target our search index.”
Manual acts are becoming rarer. Manual site reviews require time and resources; therefore, Google has worked hard to improve its algorithm’s detection of poor links. Nonetheless, manual actions may occur, particularly if you spam excessively regularly.
Manual reviews are initiated by:
- A competitor reports spam.
- Algorithm-generated issues that require human evaluation.
- Being in a spammy niche.
You will be notified in Google Search Console if you have been subjected to a manual action (penalty). It’s under ‘manual actions.
If you’ve got one, you’ll see a preview of the pages that have been affected – these can be specific portions of your site or sitewide. The afflicted pages often lose ranks before the penalty implementation, and you cannot restore those rankings until the punishment is lifted.
Before requesting reconsideration, learn how to remove the toxic backlinks that generated the penalty and disavow those you can’t remove.
Your Website Goes Through an Algorithmic Filter
The second scenario is algorithmic. Rather than a human reviewer, Google’s systems assess links automatically. Since 2016, Penguin works in real time and mostly devalues spammy links, meaning they simply stop counting, instead of pushing your whole site down.
You won’t get a notification for this, and there is nothing to appeal. If you built manipulative links in the past and they stop counting, you may see rankings settle lower, because those links were boosting your site artificially. Removing or disavowing them will not bring that boost back. The fix is to stop the practices that created them and earn genuine links instead.
If you did not build the links, you usually do not need to do anything. Google’s own guidance is that most sites do not need to use the disavow tool.
Avoid Toxic Link Building Practices
Here are link building practices that break Google’s spam policies. These are the links that can lead to a manual action, so avoid building them. Here’s how to avoid toxic backlinks.
Paid Links
Paying for a link that passes ranking credit is a clear violation of Google’s spam policies. For example, paying sponsorship charges for guest posts or gifting services or goods in exchange for a link.
However, if you use sponsored content for reasons other than link building (to leverage someone’s audience and gain referral traffic, for example), add the sponsored or nofollow link attribute to the link so it is clearly marked as paid.
Anchor Texts that Match Exactly
Exact match anchor text links are generally hazardous, regardless of source.
If you manipulate the anchor text, which must be an exact match for the keywords a page is attempting to rank, the links will appear artificial.
Blog Networks
Private blog networks (PBN) are black hat link building strategies that create and maintain collections of sites only to link to other sites.
Several black hat SEOs claim that Google would never uncover an extremely private blog network. However, even if they appear natural to an average web visitor, skilled SEOs and Google can easily spot them.
As a result, Google has been actively seeking the closure of PBNs for years, including high-profile cases dating back to 2014. Google will eventually find any PBN, and the penalties can be harsh.
Spun Article Links and Content
Building links with spun material was popular a decade ago. The strategy comprised creating one article and then employing software to generate hundreds of versions, most of which were junk. These pieces were then sent to article directories with links. Links like these break Google’s spam policies and can lead to a manual action.
Spam Blog and Forum Comments
Comment spam is another old link development practice related to harmful links. These comments are often generated by software that spams blogs with irrelevant remarks.
If you manage a WordPress site, you probably get a lot of notifications with commentaries to approve that are unrelated to the content yet contain a link. That’s spam.
A similar method is regularly used on forums, with meaningless replies but links. These links have little value. Besides, they also create a trace that Google’s algorithms may pick up on because they all point to the same page.
Widgets
Suppose you create a widget or plugin (for example, for WordPress) and distribute it with a link attached (as was once prevalent on sidebars throughout the web). In that case, you are breaking Google’s spam policies, and those links can lead to a manual action. If you offer a widget with a link, add the nofollow attribute to the link.
Mutual Link Building
While reciprocal link building (two sites linking to each other) occurs organically, if done at a large scale and the links originate from irrelevant ‘links pages,’ you will end up with many unnatural links, which Google may treat as a link scheme.
How to Spot Toxic Backlinks and Websites
Every SEO should employ tips for avoiding toxic websites and, going further, how to remove toxic backlinks. These include the following:
1. Establish Your Audit
When creating your audit, it is recommended that you study the root domain and state your brand name, followed by your target nation and category. The three fields are non-compulsory and should already be completed, but it is good to double-check them.
2. Link up Google Search Console
While the audit runs, link up SEMrush with your Google Search Console account to pull in more link data.
3. Obtain a High-Level Overview and Examine the Results
After the audit, obtain a summary of the statistics and an indicator of your backlink’s overall health profile.
Then view the whole audit findings and dig deeper into the results. For instance:

(Image Credit: Cycorp)
4. Become Acquainted with Your Link Profile
You will now see a summary of your website’s backlink profile. Look for patterns, such as many links from unrelated sites using the same keyword-rich anchor text, rather than worrying about the tool’s overall toxicity score. That score is the tool’s own estimate, not something Google uses.
5. Start Auditing Your Toxic Backlinks
Sort the results by the tool’s toxicity or risk rating so you can review the riskiest links first. Open each flagged link and ask one question: was this link bought, swapped or built to manipulate rankings?
If the answer is no and you have no manual action, you can usually leave the link alone, because Google already ignores most spammy links. Save removal requests and disavowing for links that were bought, swapped or built to manipulate rankings, especially if you have a manual action. Disavowing good links by mistake can hurt your site.
6. Create Your Whitelist
To maintain a clean environment, you’ll want to build a safelist of domains having a low hazardous score or those you know are natural and harmless. Once a link has been selected, it can be added to your ‘keep’ list.
How to Remove Toxic Backlinks
After you’ve built your safelist, you’ll be left with links you believe were bought, swapped or built to manipulate rankings. These are the only links worth acting on.
If you’ve been given a manual action for unnatural links, removing these links is the main step toward getting it lifted. If you have no manual action, Google generally recommends you leave links alone, and you can skip the removal and disavow steps unless you know paid or manipulative links were built to your site.
1. Create A To-Be-Removed List
Once you’ve picked one or more links, you can generate a delete list directly from the audit tool.
If you intend to delete these links, proceed by adding them to your ‘to remove’ list from the ‘Delete’ option. This implies you’ve located an email address to which you can send the removal request. Alternatively, you must disavow the toxic backlink.
You can also use the Remove tab to submit modification requests.
2. Connect Your Email
If you’re using Microsoft or Gmail email account, navigate to the remove page, and connect your email account to the tool. After that, submit removal requests with a single click.
Click on the add button next to the mailbox to connect your account.
3. Submit A Request for Removal
From here, submitting a removal request using specific templates is pretty straightforward. Click on the ‘send’ button to the right of the URLs in your removal list.
Then edit the template as desired, although it is generally sufficient to input the domain’s email address and click send. For example:

(Image Credit: Search Engine Journal)
4. Monitor Requests for Removal
The final stage in how to remove a toxic backlink is to pay attention to any responses you receive. This may be done in the report’s status column. You’ll be able to see at what step of the process each link is, allowing you to return to the email tool and follow up or resend if your initial email was not opened or was not responded to.
5. Move Your Removal List
You can navigate through your removal list as needed, viewing the status of each link. If you cannot remove these toxic backlinks, you must disavow them.
Disavowing Toxic Backlinks
If you have a manual action for unnatural links, or you know paid or manipulative links point to your site and you cannot get them removed, you can ask Google to ignore them with a disavow file. If neither applies, you do not need to disavow anything.
A disavow file tells Google to ignore the links you list when it assesses your site. It is an advanced tool. Google warns that using it incorrectly can harm your site’s performance in search, so only disavow links you are confident are unnatural.
1. Upload The Disavow File
Consider the following:
- When you upload a new disavow file, all previously uploaded files are overwritten.
- The user is always responsible for ensuring that the file has all previously disavowed links, not just the new ones.
- Google processes the file as it recrawls the web, which can take several weeks.
If you’ve already filed your domain’s disavow file, upload it directly to the tool’s ‘disavow’ tab. Ignore this step if this is your first time submitting a disavow file.
2. Add Links To The Disavow List
Return to the Backlink Audit, select the links you wish to disavow and click the ‘delete’ button to send them to reject. That is all. Most sites recommend disavowing at the domain level rather than the URL level, as this takes care of both sitewide links that may be problematic and any future links that may arise on the domain.
Add these domains to your disavow list.
3. Move the Disavow File
Once you are sure that the disavow list is comprehensive and have included all of the toxic backlinks that require action, you must export your disavow file. At the top right corner, you’ll find an ‘Export to TXT’ button.
This saves your disavow list as a .txt file that you can upload to Google.
4. Submit your work to Google
Proceed directly to Google’s Disavow Tool, ensuring that your Google Search Console account is logged in. Then, upload your.txt file and click submit. To see how your website is performing, you can start with a free scan on diib and compare plans on the diib pricing page.
Diib® Digital: Learn How to Remove Toxic Backlinks Today!
A regular look at your backlinks helps you understand who links to you and spot real problems early, such as links someone bought on your behalf. For most sites, though, the best use of your time is earning good links, not removing bad ones. diib’s dashboard gives you a view of your backlink profile alongside the rest of your website’s health. Here are a few of the features included:
- Bounce rate monitoring and repair
- Social media integration and performance
- Broken pages where you have backlinks (404 checker)
- Keyword (including snippets), backlink, and indexing monitoring and tracking tools
- User experience and mobile speed optimization
- Technical SEO monitoring
Click here for your free 60 second site scan or simply call 800-303-3510 to speak to one of our growth experts.
